I just completed this quest, and I must say for the 1sta 1wiz 2sp and 18m is really sad for the amount of work put in to get this quest completed. Player-made silver rings give me more mana with 3wiz and 10m. I know someone will say that 2sp and 18m is worth it, but as a healer, I do not see the difference as much. Replacing one ring, I lose 20m, and as a druid, that is a lot. All in all, great quest line as I enjoyed the journey, but the reward is really only for 2sp, which I believe we can get that elsewhere.